Tag Archives: Vertigo

Body Double (Brian de Palma, 1984)

A friend was commenting the other day on how good Brian De Palma is with actors to which my response was, ‘is he? He’s certainly great with great actors. But have you seen Craig Wasson in BODY DOUBLE’? Jake Scully is a great role, the cuckolded nebbish wannabee who breaks down in acting class, gets to be a vampire, styles up for an MTV video with Frankie goes to Hollywood, and even goes porno.  And I found him completely charmless throughout, a chore to watch. He certainly didn’t get to do much of note after its release, whereas it re-launched Melanie Griffith’s career, whose performance is what I best remembered from the film, funny and true. The film is about mediated experience, through various media and through different forms of voyeurism. It’s a kind of transmogrification of Rear Window (1954) and Vertigo (1958), but without the emotion, excitement or complexity. It’s got great moments of thrilling filmmaking (the opening and ending, the scenes at the mall, the beach, the burial, the voyeurism across the canyon). It also functions as a kind of metacinema (the uses of rear projection and their revelation, the video shop, the contrast and connection between low-budget slasher and porn, its satire on LA’s surface image culture). One can make a case for it as a great movie, and of course people have. But I do sometimes think that contemporary criticism, with its access to viewing and reviewing, re-winding, the ability to detach scenes from movies, to stop the film’s unfolding of time etc. create different types of experiences, and that critics sometimes can’t see the forest for the trees they so intensely obsess over. I remembered Melanie Griffitsh so vividly that I’d forgotten she only appears almost two thirds into the film, when it all of a sudden comes alive. Also, alongside the dazzling filmmaking, there is something derivative, and by this I mean that the Hitchcockian in BODY DOUBLE achieves only the surface effects without the underlying depth and complexity of sometimes contradictory feeling Hitchcock draws out. There’s something crude, lewd, and sleazy about the whole enterprise here. The power drill scene, a riff on the chainsaw scene in SCARFACE (1983), is milked for all its considerable sexual connotations. It’s funny but only if you put aside the extraordinary misogyny that underpins it. In AMERICAN PSYCHO Brett Easton Ellis makes of BODY DOUBLE serial killer Patrick Bateman’s favourite and most watched movie. It’s not hard to see why.

José Arroyo

OBSESSION (Brian de Palma, 1976)

OBSESSION (Brian de Palma, 1976)

 

Cliff Robertson plays Michael Courtland the businessman who loses his much-loved wife and daughter to kidnappers and is riven by guilt. When he goes to Florence with his business partner (John Lithgow) he meets a young woman who is the spitting image of his late wife and becomes obsessed, à la VERTIGO (Alfred Hitchcock,1958) a clear inspiration, following her through the dark nights of the old town until he meets her, dates her and brings her to America.

Good thing she’s a good Catholic and doesn’t put out, as the object of his affection turns out to be the daughter he’s long thought dead. Geneviève Bujold plays mother, daughter, and child-as-grown up, one of the many inventive twirls De Palma de ploys here.

She’s terrific and her work here makes me want to revisit her other work, particularly the films she made in Quebec with Paul Almond, Michel Brault and Claude Jutra. Robertson, as we can see in the clip below,  comes across as handsome but a bit stiff in contrast.

The story is filmed predominantly in very wide shots, that take in the surroundings, contrasted with close-ups, sometimes extreme ones, when the story calls for interiority or turns to dreams.

It’s a dazzling film full of rhyming shots (the mausoleum where the wife rests evokes the Church where they met, father and daughter are both filmed in the exact same place in the exact same type of shot at different moments in the film, the change in figure a change in meaning) with the last shot, a father/daughter embrace where  the camera goes 360 degrees on the impossible couple, themselves twirling with emotional release around the camera. It’s a tour de force ending to a fascinating film that as Gary Couzens says, ‘has both a 360° nd 540° pan’..

It was De Palma’s first mainstream success and Bernard Herrman’s last score (TAXI DRIVER was written later but released earlier),, a great one. Co-written by De Palman and Paul Schrader; the latter accusing the former of truncating and destroying his work (ostensibly removing or condensing the last third of the screenplay) and not speaking to him for years. But De Palma clearly made the right decision. It’s a noir infused psychological thriller with Gothic elements  that holds up beautifully, with the scenes of Robertson following the dream of his dead wife at night in Florence particularly memorable. The ending remains extraordinary. Bluray from Arrow.

José Arroyo